Laser vs. inkjet industrial coding – which is the better option?

Laser coding technology is an emerging technologysystem. Most laser marking set-ups require an
that has improved rapidly in the last 5 years in termsextraction and filtration system to safely remove the
of Speed, flexibility, print area and size. Despite someby-products of the lasing process e.g. vapors or
exciting applications laser may continue be challengedparticles such as glass particulates. As a result,
by inkjet coding for use in industrial traceability due tofrequent filter changes may be required. In addition
some intrinsic characteristics of inkjet : low cost + highlaser coder parts such as the laser tube and coding
speed, variety of inks compatible to substrates, nonhead may need replacing depending on use. New
permanency of marking, Thermo-cromic colour changefilters and spare parts are costs that should be
etc.considered over the long-term use of the equipment.
In reality laser and inkjet are complementaryLaser coding offer many benefits such as a
technologies. Some operations may have anpermanent mark that is virtually impossible to alter
application that allows for both technologies equally,without evidence. The vector technology enables very
however in many cases after the correct analysis; theaesthetically appealing graphics, text and multiple lines
choice will be clear-cut.(if speed permits). The cosmetics industry has found
Markem-Imaje has extensive experience in bothapplications to ensure branding is not negatively
technologies through its broad product range andaffected by unattractive traceability marking and have
appreciates the merits and limitations of both systems.reduced the possibility of counterfeiting. The cost
Every application should be individually assessed toeffectiveness of using a laser is impressive as it uses
establish the most suitable technology required.virtually no consumables, resulting in lower ongoing
Elements to consider are the substrate, linerunning costs (excluding spare parts).
requirements (eg speed), the desired message, theAs with all technology, there will always be some
physical environment and of course budget.limitations and laser coding is no different. The main
Different substrates require different laser energylimitation is that not all substrates can be marked
levels to 'change' and mark the surface. As a result,effectively: reflective substrates such as metal (eg
laser-marking systems are available in variety ofaluminum or steel cans) cannot be marked and some
power ratings, measured in watts. Markem-Imaje hasglass is very difficult to mark and would require a very
a range of laser units, starting at the 10 watt system,high-powered laser to do so.
and progressing up to the top end of the market withBeing environmentally conscious and responsible, it is
the 7000 series at 200-250 watts, utilizing Rofinimportant to know that recycling laser marked
technology - world leaders in industrial laser technology.products is only possible if the packaging is
There is invariably a trade-off between power andreconstituted (eg melted or pulped down.) In contrast,
speed. As such there are effectively three elementsinkjets can use specialised inks that enable inkjet
of laser technology to consider: the substrate to becoding to be removed in alkaline baths. Another fact to
marked, line speed and message complexity.consider is that while laser coders may not use
If the surface is easy to lase, such as paper orconsumables that produce emissions, the by-products
cardboard, a low powered laser may be adequate.produced by a laser as it marks the substrate can be
However if production lines are traveling at medium totoxic or dangerous. Depending on the substrate being
high speed or the message is complex, a moremarked, the environment and quantity of by-product
powerful laser is necessary to compensate.produced, filter systems may be required to remove
Additionally, if the surface is hard or difficult to markvapors and particles. Integrating laser equipment
then more power is required even before line speed isrequires rigorous safety precautions, special physical
considered.barriers and sufficient space around the machine and
The most widely promoted benefit of laser coding isongoing staff training. This can be both an expensive
the absence of traditional consumables. Laser codingand timely exercise. In contrast, inkjet can easily be
systems do not require ink or additives as inkjettransported between production lines and set up for
printers do. However there are some requirements,production runs.
other than power, necessary to safely operate a laser